Blog

Blog - desktop

Who exactly are we protecting?

#freewoman #chiclibertinage #modernfemininity #feminineconfidences #mybodymychoice

For over fifteen years, Giacomo has handled the camera while I’ve held the pen. We film our adventures; I tell the stories and publish them here. Part of the site is open to the public, while the rest is reserved for adult subscribers. There is nothing illicit or forced about it: two adults, a shared project, and a lot of enjoyment in carrying it out.

 

So, when I read in *Journal du Geek* that OnlyFans might soon be banned in France, I read the sentence twice. Then I went looking for the details, because I can’t help myself: the engineer in me always wants to read the specifications before judging the feature.

 

And as I read, I realized I was looking at two very different things lumped under the same label.


Two texts, two targets

The first text comes from the Senate. Senator Marie Mercier (LR) is sponsoring a bill targeting the agents and intermediaries of adult content creators on platforms like OnlyFans and Mym. According to Euronews, the text was rewritten during debates to create a new offense modeled on human trafficking laws. It mandates a seven-year prison sentence and a €150,000 fine for online sexual exploitation, with harsher penalties if the victim is a minor. It is now set to go before the National Assembly.

 

The second is Article 25 of Bill No. 3106 regarding sexual and gender-based violence against women and children. The Assembly’s special committee adopted it between September 21 and 23, and the text is scheduled for a floor vote on October 1. This article would expand the legal definition of procuring (*proxénétisme*) to include paid sexual acts performed remotely and would punish the buyer with a fine. As *Journal du Geek* and the law firm Kohen Avocats explain, OnlyFans and Mym are directly affected.

 

Do you see the difference?

 

The first provision targets the person doing the exploiting.
The second targets the exchange itself, and the person paying.


Yes, a thousand times yes, to protection

Let me be clear: I support the first provision.

 

In its opinion dated July 16, the Council of State noted that no existing offense currently covers the exploitation of remote sexual acts by a third party, and that legislation was therefore required. (I admit I haven't read the opinion itself, only what the articles report about it.) But the conclusion speaks for itself. If someone can profit from another person's body from behind a screen without any law allowing for prosecution, there is a hole in the safety net. It needs to be mended.

 

Reports also indicate that relationships between managers and creators are shifting toward written contracts with commission caps. Here again, that seems like common sense to me. A written contract is the primary form of protection for the person signing it. You know what you are giving, what you are keeping, and who is owed what.

 

In the world of swinging and libertinism, consent is non-negotiable. I have always said this, and I see no reason why it should be any different when a camera and payment are involved. A woman who is coerced, threatened, or stripped of her earnings is not free. She needs protection, and the person exploiting her must be held accountable.


No to confiscation

It is Article 25 that bothers me. Since 2016, clients of sex workers have faced a €1,500 fine, rising to €3,750 for repeat offenses. Until now, however, the law required physical contact. Article 25 removes that condition. It is no longer just about prosecuting the exploiter; it is about defining the exchange itself, taking place remotely between adults, and penalizing the person who pays.

 

I am not a lawyer, and I do not yet know exactly where the line will be drawn. Do the videos I film with my husband and offer via subscription fall within this scope? Would my subscribers become clients subject to fines? I don't have the answer, and it is precisely this ambiguity that worries me. Criminal law ought to be the most precise text in the world.

 

But beyond my own situation, it is the underlying logic that troubles me. It took decades to gain acceptance for the idea that a woman alone decides what to do with her body. "My body, my choice", the slogan was shouted loud enough to be heard. And yet, an exception is now being made the moment a screen and a payment are involved. As if a choice ceases to be a choice the moment it generates income. As if any woman who shows herself is inevitably an unwitting victim.

 

I remember one evening in a hotel parking lot, standing nearly naked beneath my trench coat. For a moment, I felt like an "escort." Anyone who saw me would inevitably think whatever they pleased. Then I decided to let people think whatever they wanted, and I walked inside. Over the years, I have learned to let that kind of gaze simply slide off me. But when the law is behind it, it no longer slides quite so easily.

 

An objection I raise against myself

You might say, and you’d be right, that I have a "real" job. I’m an engineer; I run my own business. My films pay for nice vacations and my lingerie, nothing more. I’m not a star, and I don’t rely on that income. I can afford to be angry without my rent depending on it.

 

But that is precisely why I worry about the women who *do* make a living from this. According to reports, banks are already demanding more documentation for accounts linked to adult content. No specific figures are cited, it’s just an observation, but it speaks volumes: suspicion is taking hold even before a law is passed. If we push this activity further to the margins, are we really protecting the women involved? Or are we leaving them more isolated, more vulnerable, and, ironically, more exposed to the very middlemen we wanted to free them from?

 

I’ve turned the question over in my mind, and I see no contradiction between defending victims and defending freedom. In fact, I believe they go hand in hand. Punishing the exploiter protects the freedom of the person he exploited. Punishing the exchange itself strips that freedom away from all the others.

 

On 13th October, lawmakers will make their decision.

 

Protecting those who are victimized, yes. But who will think of those who choose this path?

 

 

Sources

ALL COMMENTS
Sois le premier à commenter :)
USERS
Connexion au chat en cours... Loading...
Connexion en cours... Loading...
{{userLogin}}